Published on Sep 2, 1998
Luther Vandross is quite simply one of the finest singers in
popular music today. You would be hard pressed to find another
singer with such a sweet, expressive, soulful voice, especially in
the adult contemporary genre as it stands where the histrionic
over-the-top singing of Whitney Houston is preferred. On his 1996
release,
Your Secret Love, Vandross, definitely a pro at this point,
has created a well-crafted album that should please fans. However,
he has also created an album that fails to avoid some of the
pitfalls and flaws found in many adult contemporary releases.
Vandross, who also produced
Your Secret Love, wisely starts off with the winning title
track. He needed a strong single to follow up 1994’s “The Power Of
Love” and he got it here on this midtempo ballad. Vandross’ singing
expresses effectively the apprehension of being the other man in a
secret relationship. His singing shines again on the winsome ballad
“It’s Hard For Me To Say” about a guy too shy to express his
love.
“I Can’t Wait No Longer (Let’s Do This)” is probably the most
talked about song on this collection because he duets with rapper
Deidra “Spin” Roper of the group Salt N’ Pepa. This playful track
adds a needed contemporary touch to the album. If you think this
combination is as absurd as Metallica working with Marianne
Faithful, don’t forget that Vandross is not only a ballad singer
but can sing R&B as well, and here his singing does compliment
Roper’s rapping.
But Vandross’ forte is his interpretation of other people’s
songs, so it is no surprise that this album boasts two inspired
covers. He tackles the little known Stevie Wonder tune “Knocks Me
Off My Feet” and revives the old standard “Goin’ Out Of My Head”
making both of them his own. Nat Adderley Jr.’s arrangements
compliment these songs with a light jazz feel. “Crazy Love” (not
the Van Morrison song, but written by a group of songwriters) is
one of those show-stopping type of ballads that Vandross sings the
heck out of without sucking the life from it.
But now here are the pitfalls: the second single “I Can Make It
Better” is an uptempo number with very little life to it. And “Love
Don’t Love Here Anymore” and “Too Proud To Beg” are good titles but
are uninspired, by the book type ballads. Then there are “Nobody To
Love”, “Whether Or Not The World Gets Better”, and “This Time I’m
Right” which are nice songs individually, but they all have very
similar melodies and unfortunately are sequenced together.
And here lies the problem with
Your Secret Love: Vandross is a better singer than
songwriter, but here he has written, at least in part, eight of the
twelve selections. Sure, some of his songs are very good, but he
does not have enough of those to fill an album. Nevertheless, if
Your Secret Love isn’t exactly a masterpiece, it is a
pleasant listen. Vandross once again has turned in a masterful
performance.