Published on Feb 14, 2005
The seventies-funk keyboards, the understated r & b electric
guitar, the smoldering, sublimely soulful vocals — if these guys
aren’t Stevie Wonder fans, I really need to quit this gig.
My first impression of Maroon 5 — courtesy of the single
“Harder to Breathe” — was simply of a modern pop-rock singles band
with a sound that stood out. They were smooth without being slick,
muscular without being heavy, didn’t rely on beefy guitars or
clichéd lyrics, and had a singer who put some artistry into
his performance. Burrowing into this album over time, though,
introduced me to a band — James Valentine on guitar, Jesse
Carmichael on keys, Mickey Madden on bass, Ryan Dusick on drums and
Adam Levine on lead vocals — that has one foot in the past and one
in the future, and has figured out how to bridge the two in a form
that consistently entertains.
Take, for example, “Sunday Morning,” one of the best cuts here.
You might expect a song about morning-after contentment to feel
languid, but Dusick, Madden, Valentine and Carmichael set a deep,
sweet groove here that leaves Levine to decorate the upper register
with his nimble, expressive vocals, full of swerving, exuberant
Wonder-isms. Sunny harmonies and a funked-out bridge round out this
fairly brilliant piece of pop-soul songsmithing.
This is hardly a one-note band, though. The leadoff cut (and
leadoff single) “Harder To Breathe” is a steamy rocker; the slinky
synth/acoustic guitar opening to “Secret” sets the mood
beautifully; and old-school keyboards — clavinet and Hammond,
mostly, from the sound of it — add spice and texture to jamming
numbers like “The Sun.”
Less imaginative cuts like “This Love” and “Not Coming Home”
veer dangerously close to boy-band dynamics in places, but still
throw off undeniable energy. And while it might not be the most
original track here, “She Will Be Loved” is surely one of the
prettiest love songs of the young century, buoyed by Levine’s
brilliant use of falsetto on the chorus.
The story goes that the lyrics of these
Songs About Jane all grew out of a breakup experienced by
Levine. It must have been quite a relationship, as these tracks
feature an often Marvin Gaye-like focus on the perils and rewards
of physical passion (ex: “I tried my best to feed her appetite /
Keep her coming every night”; “Fingers trace your every outline /
Paint a picture with my hands”).
After seeing these guys perform “Sunday Morning” on
The Today Show, though, I have to say that the most
remarkable thing about them is watching four young white guys lay
down a killer r & b groove as the voice of a born soul singer
emerges from the body of a skinny Jewish kid. The Red Hot Chili
Peppers’ remake of the Stevie Wonder classic “Higher Ground”
transformed the song almost completely. A Maroon 5 version might be
tough to tell from the original until you opened your eyes — and
that’s far from a criticism.