Midnite Vultures – Sean McCarthy

Midnite Vultures
Geffen Records, 1999
Reviewed by Sean McCarthy
Published on Dec 3, 1999

Midnite Vultures is supposed to be Beck’s “Dumb party album”
of the year. Leave it to Beck to pull something off like this. He’s
got enough props from critics to fill Steve Forbes and Donald
Trump’s heads.

To get the understatement out of the way, Beck is unpredictable.
One moment he’s begging you to pass the doochie from coast to
coast. The next moment, he’s this shy, quiet, reflective guy who is
crafting some pretty moving songwriting on
Mutations. The easiest route to a new album would be to
“combine the two” styles into one album. But Beck knows that task
would be all too easy.

Instead,
Midnite Vultures shakes, swivels and rocks. The chorus, “I
want to defy the logic of all sex laws” and the empowering line,
“And make all the lesbians scream,” is about as political as Beck
gets on
Midnite Vultures. Beck already knows he has most critics in
his pocket. On this album, he wants to hang with the B-boys.

That’s what makes songs like “Get Real Paid,” such a blast. But
for all the “bitch slap,” lines Beck drops, he is a musician in the
truest form. Each song on
Midnite Vultures is fairly rooted in a steady,
groove-oriented rhythm. The fact that he rehearsed this album with
a live band instead of his typical “handle every aspect” tactic
establishes a breezy flow to
Midnite Vultures.

However, groove-oriented doesn’t necessarily translate into
being accessible. Much like
Mutations,
Midnite Vultures will take some getting used to. A couple of
listens. Maybe even a couple of months before a final judgement can
be rendered. But there’s enough variety in the album to keep you
coming back.

The ’70s is Beck’s obsession on
Midnite Vultures. This will probably not come as much of a
surprise to most Beck fans. Dylan-esque folk and funk have been two
prominent influences on most of Beck’s songs. But Beck seems to be
taking some pointers from “The Artis…” URHHH…”TERRORIST” on
this album as well. (Damned editor politics.)

The song, “Peaches And Cream,” is the song “The TERRORIST” has
been wanting to make for the past decade. “Milk And Honey,” another
highlight on
Midnite Vultures, incorporating both interesting musical
transitions as well as head-scratching rhyming choices.

Does
Midnite Vultures have drawbacks? Yes, depending on how you
look at it. You can almost see this album as Beck’s version of
Ill Communication by the Beastie Boys. That was the first
album where the formula greatness started to feel like a
formula.

But taken as a whole,
Midnite Vultures is a great listen. It may not create a
revolution like some of his previous releases, but it stands just
fine as one of the better releases this year. So what if it is not
an undisputed masterpiece? A win streak is still a win streak.

Rating: B+

Leave a Reply