Published on Oct 19, 2004
Pop quiz boys and girls; Your debut album has become the best
selling debut album ever, with the lead single reaching number one
on the billboard charts. What do you do? Well, if you’re Boston,
you take two years to follow up with another album, one that is
almost a carbon copy of the groundbreaking
Boston. Is that bad thing?
Think of it this way:
Don’t Look Back was in the same boat as
Star Wars Episode 1. Neither could live up to expectations,
no matter how incredible the product turned out to be. Also, put
yourself in Tom Scholz’s shoes; why would you mess with a formula
that made you a great deal of money, and was widely accepted? It
would be tough for most of us to resist. So here we are presented
with an album that is derivative in every sense of the word,
however, it isn’t that bad.
What made Boston a success (and the lack thereof which led to
later stinkers like
Walk On and
Corporate America) was, among other things, that Scholz
could write a catchy rock song.
Boston had “More Than A Feeling”, so
Don’t Look Back has the title track. One of the better
tracks the band has done, “Don’t Look Back” is the perfect arena
rock anthem. Loud, good riff to start things off, refrain full of
hooks, and in a touch I like, shifts in tempo, with spots for the
customary solo. If there ever was a formula for a hit single, this
is it.
Everyone always remember the hits, so what does the rest of the
album have to offer? A few average tracks, a completely useless
instrumental, and three of the best songs Boston has to offer. With
the exception of “Feelin Satisfied,” the title track, and “A Man
I’ll Never Be,” the remaining tracks on
Don’t Look Back are your average pop/rock fare. As I
mentioned before, any of these songs could have also been on
Boston’s debut album, so after an album and half of the same songs,
the second half of
Don’t Look Back loses momentum. This could have been solved
with a better arrangement of the songs themselves.
How much you like this album depends on how much you like the
Boston sound. There is no doubt that the production on this album
is stellar, it just comes down the tunes. “It’s Easy” is a light
affair, “Don’t Be Afraid” has a strange, neo-country sound to it
that doesn’t quite work, and “Party,” as it turns out is more of a
bar mitzvah. These songs have the standard Scholz treatment, but
fail to present anything new. Now for the good news.
While there were many great moments on Boston, to me the
pinnacle of the album was the opener, ” More Than A Feeling.” On
Don’t Look Back, that pinnacle comes in the form of “A Man I’ll
Never Be.” In a very un-Boston like move, the song opens up with
just lead singer Brad Delp and the piano, and slowly gathers more
and more momentum, and Delp’s vocals climb higher and higher, until
you think the man is going to bust a nut. And of course, all this
time, Scholz’s virtuoso layering of the guitars matches Delp note
for note. This is the Boston formula, and it’s carried off
perfectly.
Don’t Look Back is not a bad record. It just could have been
better. I said this in my
Corporate America review, but don’t get confused,
CA and
Don’t Look Back are not the same record, not by a long shot.
It comes down to this; if you are going to get a Boston album, get
the debut or the greatest hits, and you’ll be set.