Christmas – Christopher Thelen

Christmas
American Gramaphone Records, 1984
Reviewed by Christopher Thelen
Published on Dec 20, 2000

Chip Davis probably didn’t realize it in 1984, but he was about
to release an album which would become a holiday standard.

Christmas, the first seasonal release from Davis’s personal
project Mannheim Steamroller, was unique in that it took New Age
music and combined it with both modern influences and old-world
carols. Admittedly, the logic of the project doesn’t hit you on the
first listen, but this disc quickly grows on you.

Most everyone has heard the synthesizer-laden version of “Deck
The Halls” by now, with its poppy beat and layered instrumentation.
This was a sign of things to come for Davis and crew: respecting
the heart of the original while putting their own unique spin on
things.

Sometimes this works well, as on their renditions of “We Three
Kings” and the group of four old carols known collectively as
“Christmas Sweet”. By keeping the style of these tracks in a
Medieval mindframe, they capture most likely what it would have
been like to hear these songs during an English Rennaissance
Christmas.

Sometimes, though, it doesn’t quite work as well as it might
have looked on paper. The full band version of “God Rest Ye Merry,
Gentlemen” and their take on “Good King Wenceslas” are lacking a
bit, though they’re hardly fall-on-your-face failures. They just
don’t seem to fit the frame of reference that Davis and crew were
most likely aiming for.

The song that seals things for me is their loving touch on
“Stille Nacht,” which is treated with the utmost of reverence. Best
known to many as “Silent Night,” Mannheim Steamroller actually has
a song here that tries to capture the true meaning of the holidays,
and even after all these years, this track brings tears to my
eyes.

So what has made
Christmas become a standard? Possibly it’s because nobody
else was doing this when Davis and crew first released this to the
masses. Possibly it’s the way the band takes so many chances, both
by dipping into the past and utilizing the present technology (at
least in 1984 standards). Maybe it’s because it allowed people to
hear the same old carols in a new light.

All I know is that
Christmas, despite one or two small slips, has remained a
holiday favorite for many people, and is waiting to be embraced by
generations to come. I’ve had my copy of this for 10 years now, and
it still gets its share of holiday play in my house.

Rating: B

Leave a Reply