Published on Aug 30, 2005
At last we come to the ubiquitous boxed set. It used to be this
was the last wave goodbye of bands long past their “use by” date.
Now it seems like every artist has one, even bands that probably
don’t warrant it. They dump them on an unsuspecting public in
various guises — some are just bigger and more expensive “best of”
collections and some are true treasure troves of alternate takes,
live versions, b-sides and other unreleased material.
In the case of Led Zeppelin, they released two box sets,
cleverly titled
Box Set Vol. 1 and
Box Set Vol. 2. I guess that’s fitting for a band that only
used numbers for their first four albums, and the fourth one didn’t
even get an official number, just some weird runes. Sorry, I
digress…
In the Rusk household, as we sit around the fire passing on the
ancient wisdom of Rock & Roll, we teach the children that a
good box set should serve one of two purposes:
1. Compile an essential collection that offers the listener a
concise snapshot of highlights of the artist’s career or, 2. Offer
hard to find material, or material not previously available
elsewhere
Vol. 1 does an excellent job of the first point. This
compilation is a great collection of indeed, the best of Zep’s
catalog. It includes their biggest hits like “Stairway To Heaven,”
“Black Dog,” “Whole Lotta Love,” and “Kashmir,” along with some
true gems that don’t get quite the exposure they deserve, songs
like “Babe I’m Gonna Leave You,” “Ramble On” and “Over the Hills
and Far Away.” Mixed in no discernible order across four discs,
this set would serve well for someone who wants a fairly
comprehensive collection of Zep’s best work without buying their
entire catalog. Almost without exception, the songs selected (Jimmy
Page chose the tracks personally) truly are the best to be found on
their nine studio albums.
As for my second point noted above, there isn’t a lot here that
doesn’t appear elsewhere, but it does include the classic rock
radio staple “Hey Hey What Can I Do” for the first time on any
album, and a very nice live version of the instrumental “White
Summer/Black Mountain Side.”
On to
Vol. 2. This is a sort of collection of leftovers, most of
which is decidedly non-essential with some big exceptions. It
includes a couple of stellar tracks like “The Rover,” “Out On The
Tiles,” “Bring It On Home” and “Living Loving Maid (She’s Just A
Woman).” These songs should be on
Vol. 1, preferably replacing mediocre fodder like “Candy
Store Rock.” When set alongside
Vol.1, the band’s entire studio catalog is represented. In
the end it is unnecessary to buy both of these; you’d be better off
just buying the entire catalog instead. However, if you want a
healthy dose of Led Zeppelin to beef up your collection,
Vol.1 fits the bill perfectly.