Published on Aug 3, 1999
I admit that I’m not the biggest listener to urban contemporary
music. It’s not that I don’t like it, or that I’ll turn it off the
moment it comes on the radio in my car; it’s just that I’ve never
really developed a big taste for it. I can appreciate hearing
artists like Boyz II Men or Luther Vandross, and I enjoy some songs
in this vein. But if there’s any genre that I could afford to be
taken to school for, urban contemporary is it.
Lo and behold, in the mail comes
BET Best Of Planet Groove, a compilation of some of today’s
biggest and brightest names in the genre. There is literally
something for everyone on this disc, and while I can’t say I liked
every performance, there was enough on this disc to make me more
interested in the urban contemporary genre.
This 15-song disc collects many of the names that even a casual
listener would recognize (Janet – anyone know why she won’t use her
last name of Jackson?, Boyz II Men, Mariah Carey), as well as some
others that might not be as well-known (Chico, Jon B.) if you don’t
follow the scene. A lot of the tracks intermix raps with the smooth
deliveries, which is not always the most welcome marriage of
styles, depending on how it’s delivered.
I would like to wonder out loud why the selection from Erykah
Badu, “Tyrone,” had several words edited out – I mean, I can figure
out which words they were quickly. But I would have rather heard
the song in its entirety, cursing and all, to truly appreciate it
the way that Badu obviously wanted it performed. I guess I’ll have
to go pick up a copy of
Live to hear the original.
The difficulty with reviewing an album like
BET Best Of Planet Groove is that whether you’ll like it or
not is a matter of personal tastes. For my part, I’m not that big
on Jackson or Carey’s recent work, so I can’t say that “I Get
Lonely” or “Breakdown” (the latter pairing Carey with Krayzie Bone
& Wish Bone) made me warm up to either singer’s work. Likewise,
my first real tastes of Sparkle (featuring R. Kelly on “Be
Careful”) and Montel Jordan (“Let’s Ride,” featuring Master P &
Silk ‘The Shocker’) were anything I’d want to write home about.
Then again, there were some performances that blew me away.
LSG’s contribution (“My Body”) was an interesting change of pace,
while Jon B. (“They Don’t Know”) and Chico featuring Joe (“No
Guarantee”) all made me interested in hearing more from these
artists. In fact, the last third of the disc turned out to contain
the strongest material, featuring artists like SWV (“Rain”) and
Xscape (“The Arms Of The One Who Loves You”).
And then, there was “A Song For Mama,” the contribution from
Boyz II Men. If you are not moved by this song, you must have ice
water running through your veins. Why this song didn’t steamroll
the charts the way that “End Of The Road” did a few years ago is
beyond me; this song, simply put, is possibly the best work that
this group has ever done.
Is a disc like
BET Best Of Planet Groove going to make you instantly
knowledgeable about urban contemporary music? Honestly, no. But it
will generate interest in the groups who are leading the way
nowadays, and might just make you interested in hearing more from
these artists. And that, I think, is the whole point of the
disc.