Achtung Baby – Sean McCarthy

Achtung Baby
U2
Island Records, 1991
Reviewed by Sean McCarthy
Published on Nov 17, 2004

The Beatles going psychedelic on
Rubber Soul. Dylan plugging in the electricity on
Highway 61 Revisited. Metallica embracing pop on
Metallica. These are the moments that are called “great
departures” for bands. For many fans, these are the moments that
define fans as ‘pre’ — (fill in the era) and ‘post.’

It wouldn’t be an understatement to say that U2’s
Achtung Baby represented one of the greatest departures for
a mainstream band in rock music history. And what a departure it
was: U2 was basically throwing away the modesty, sparseness and
mostly traditional straightforward rock arrangements in favor of
avant garde feedback, irony-rich lyrics and enough camp to set the
stage for one of the greatest rock concert spectacles of all time.
This was not your 80s-era U2. It was the dawn of the 1990s and U2
were one of the first major artists to try and define what they
wanted the 1990s to mean.

It was a humongous risk for U2. One of the most common praises
said about
The Joshua Tree was from fans saying U2 was bringing back
“realness and authenticity” to mainstream music. Now, their hero
was trading in his cowboy hat and a leather vest for wraparound
shades and eel-skin-shiny leather jackets. Surprisingly, the uproar
from most fans was relatively restrained. True, some fans did run
for cover from the dirty opening riff of “Zoo Station,” but for the
most part, fans came to warm to this new alien baby after
“Mysterious Ways” and “One” became singles.

Much of
Achtung Baby was recorded in Berlin. Recorded around the
same time of the collapse of the Berlin Wall, the band was letting
German-style club beats and Middle Eastern riffs into its arsenal.
In a time where the world was falling in love with Nirvana’s
stripped down aesthetics, it was welcoming to have an album with
this grand of a spectacle.
Achtung Baby was one of those time-spanning rarities in
rock: a big, conceptual album that bled a very human heart.

“So Cruel” and “Love is Blindness” were some of U2’s darkest
songs. Even the more optimistic tunes, such as “Acrobat” and “One”
had a black sheen of melancholy coated over their hopeful messages.
Hell, the chorus of “Acrobat” was “Don’t let the bastards grind you
down.” The Edge helped make this transitioning period easier for
fans to digest with some of his finest work. “The Fly” and “Even
Better Than The Real Thing” were irresistible air guitar moments
for music geeks.

Achtung Baby yielded Zoo TV, a tour that still has the
ability to bond Gen-Xers. Be it fans discussing what city they
caught Zoo TV, who Bono called on the satellite phone during the
concert or the opening act (The Sugarcubes, Disposable Heroes of
Hiphopricy, The Pixies or Primus), fans seem to share their own
stories about their experiences more readily than any other concert
in the 1990s, including Lollapalooza.

Achtung Baby could have been a career suicide album for U2.
Instead, it freed them up of the pretension that came to make them
the butt of jokes after
The Joshua Tree. Music-wise, the album absolutely rocks. The
futuristic sounds that hit listeners were equally matched by tunes
that could have been heard in pre-war Berlin. The result was a
timeless piece of music that hasn’t aged a bit.

Rating: A

Leave a Reply