Iron Maiden – Riley McDonald

Iron Maiden
Raw Power Records, 1980
Reviewed by Riley McDonald
Published on Sep 7, 2004

The year is 1980. Martin Scorsese’s film
Raging Bull is released; President Carter boycotts the
Olympics; and in England, heavy metal is on the rise with the likes
of Judas Priest and Motörhead. One club band, having only a
small following will release an album that will be the harbinger
for the future of not only New Wave of British Heavy Metal, but
metal as a whole.

The lineup on
Iron Maiden is radically different from the one most people
know and love. Dennis Stratton is playing on rhythm guitars instead
of Adrian Smith or Janick Gers. On the drums is the slightly less
popular, yet by no means less great Clive Burr. The most noticeable
person missing is the Air Raid Siren, Bruce Dickinson, who wouldn’t
hook up with the band for another two years. Instead, we’re treated
to the much more coarse, harsh, and punk-oriented Paul Di’Anno.
While I can’t say I enjoy him more than Bruce, he’s still adept at
what he does.

Unfortunately, this would be one of the band’s weakest releases.
The production seems to be really poor (though you can’t really
fault the band for that), and some of the musicianship seems to be
fairly shoddy (“Remember Tomorrow,” while being one of my favourite
tracks on the album, has a weird, dissonant intro to it that makes
me cringe every time I hear it).

This is not to say that this is a bad album at all. It has some
of Maiden’s biggest hits on it, such as the rocking instrumental
“Transylvania,” the hard rock anthem of “Running Free,” and, of
course, “Iron Maiden.” In fact, the softer “ballad” “Remember
Tomorrow,” is one of the high points, along with the ferocious,
relentless “Phantom of the Opera,” with its brilliant instrumental
section that would show some foreshadowing on Harris and Smith’s
excellence in the writing department.

However, the album is marred with the juvenile perversity of
“Prowler,” (though I have to admit, that intro riff is catchy as
hell), and the failed parody of love ballads called “Charlotte The
Harlot.” Also, I find the much-loved hit “Sanctuary” to be sorely
lacking. It’s these beginners mistakes that show not all of
Maiden’s material have held up over the past 20+ years.

Whenever I’m listening to this album, I find it better to think
of it not as an Iron Maiden release, but rather as an NWoBHM
record. To me, this album is an adequate symbol for the whole of
British Heavy Metal of the era, capturing both the good and the
bad.

In all, this album is hardly a bad one by metal standards, but
hardly a good one by Maiden standards. I’d recommend this album,
but only after people have checked out some of the band’s better
works.

Rating: B-

Leave a Reply